LES FRÈRES LE NAIN (LAON VERS 1588-VERS 1677 PARIS) - photo 1
LES FRÈRES LE NAIN (LAON VERS 1588-VERS 1677 PARIS) - photo 2
LES FRÈRES LE NAIN (LAON VERS 1588-VERS 1677 PARIS) - photo 3

LES FRÈRES LE NAIN (LAON VERS 1588-VERS 1677 PARIS)

Lot 24
21.11.2024 16:00UTC +00:00
Classic
Sold
€ 37 800
AuctioneerCHRISTIE'S
Event locationUnited Kingdom, London
Buyer Premiumsee on Website%
Archive
The auction is completed. No bids can be placed anymore.
Archive
ID 1336077
Lot 24 | LES FRÈRES LE NAIN (LAON VERS 1588-VERS 1677 PARIS)
Estimate value
€ 40 000 – 60 000
LES FRÈRES LE NAIN (LAON VERS 1588-VERS 1677 PARIS)
Les Enfants à la cage
huile sur toile
41,6 x 31,1 cm (16 3/8 x 12 ¼ in.)




Provenance

Dr. Hans Wendland (1880-1965), Lugano ; sa vente, Graupe, Berlin, 24-25 avril 1931, lot 56 (comme Louis Le Nain) ;
Acquis au cours de celle-ci par une collection particulière ;
Puis par descendance dans la famille ; vente anonyme, Christie's, New York, 27 janvier 2000, lot 174 (comme attribué à Mathieu Le Nain) ;
Acquis au cours de celle-ci par l'actuel propriétaire.



Literature

Internationale Sammler-Zeitung, 15 mai 1931, 23e année, 10, p. 110 (comme Louis Le Nain).
J. Thuillier, Les Frères Le Nain, [cat. exp.], Paris, 1978, p. 195, sous le n°31 (comme '[...] sa qualité semblait haute, et nous regrettons de n'avoir pu retrouver sa trace').
P. Rosenberg, Tout L'Oeuvre Peint Des Le Nain, Paris, 1993, p. 88, n°62B (comme '[une] version plus petite avec d'importantes variantes [du tableau de Karlsruhe]'), reproduit en noir et blanc.
P. Rosenberg, Poussin, Lorrain, Watteau, Fragonard..., [cat. exp.], Paris, 2005, p. 171, sous le n°86 (comme '[version] avec variantes').
N. Milovanovic, Les frères Le Nain : Bons génies de la sympathie humaine, Paris, 2019, p. 158, n°18 (comme 'nous pencherions pour le groupe "Louis" pour le tableau qui nous intéresse ici').



Further details

THE BROTHERS LE NAIN (C. 1588-C. 1677), CHILDREN WITH A CAGE, OIL ON CANVAS

The present composition stands out in the oeuvre of the Le Nain brothers (c. 1588-c. 1677) for the whimsy of its subject matter. The two brothers standing around the barrel contemplate an empty bird cage, whilst between them an uncharacteristically contrite cat is sitting, the implication being that the cat has succumbed to his feline nature and eaten the bird. Two versions of this composition are known, each with slight differences: the present painting, with its wonderfully dusky palette, and a second in the Staatliche Kunsthalle, Karlsruhe, which has a darker, more robust color scheme (inv. no. 2544). When François-Rolland Elluin (1745-1822) made an engraving after the Karlsruhe version he underlined the anecdotal nature of the painting by giving it the title Le Voleur pris – the captured thief.

In his 1978 exhibition catalogue, Jacques Thuillier (op. cit. p. 196) suggests that this choice of subject may place both paintings at the beginning of the brothers’ production, slightly before 1640. Imbued as they are with a great sense of calm, both paintings are a far cry from the contemporary popular burlesque prints that depicted children playing with animals. However, it is undoubtedly in this vein that they would have been understood, which suggests that were executed whilst the Le Nain brothers were still searching out the more detached, slightly haunting style that marked their later scenes of peasant life.

As well as the difference in color palette between the present painting and the Karlsruhe version, a number of other differences can be highlighted. Most importantly, the choice here to situate the scene inside the wonderfully ramshackle building, which helps to anchor the still-life elements at lower right. In contrast those in the German version float slightly awkwardly. The difference between the two paintings has naturally led to speculation as to which of the brothers might have painted which example.

Much time has been expended by scholars in trying to distinguish the hands of the artistic collective that were the Le Nain brothers, Antoine (ca. 1598-1648), Louis (ca. 1600/1605-1648) and Mathieu (ca. 1607-1677). They produced altarpieces and religious paintings; portraits; small, multifigural pictures of musicians or children, such as the present painting; and peasant scenes. They achieved considerable success, received commissions from the Church and Crown and were founding members of the Académie royale, established just two months before the near simultaneous deaths of Antoine and Louis, presumably from the same illness. Some of their paintings are signed, but when they are, it is always simply 'Le Nain'. Some of the pictures are clearly collaborations involving more than one hand, but three groupings of pictures have been proposed which appear to represent distinct hands, and which are tentatively assigned to individual brothers. Roughly divided, the small multifigural paintings on copper and wood are given to Antoine (or brother A), in part because Antoine was described in an early source (Claude Leleu’s Histoire de Laon, written before 1726) as having 'excelled at miniatures and small portraits'; the peasant interiors are generally given to Louis Le Nain (or brother B); while Mathieu (or brother C) – who lived and worked for 30 years after the deaths of his brothers – is given the widest range of pictures, including most of the large-scale paintings and biblical subjects, as well the paintings which, for one reason or another, can only have been made after the deaths of Antoine and Louis.

Being able to directly compare two versions of the same composition that display such a different handling of the material, as is the case here, is tantalizing. It has been tentatively suggested that the Karlsruhe painting may be ascribed to Mathieu and that the present painting may be the work of Louis; however, this remains speculative.
Address of auction CHRISTIE'S
8 King Street, St. James's
SW1Y 6QT London
United Kingdom
Preview
21.11.2024 – 21.11.2024
Phone +44 (0)20 7839 9060
Email
4FQ.AYGKAGLUQ@FO3G@
Buyer Premium see on Website
Conditions of purchaseConditions of purchase

More from Creator

THE LE NAIN BROTHERS (LAON C. 1607-C.1677 PARIS)
THE LE NAIN BROTHERS (LAON C. 1607-C.1677 PARIS)
$120 000

Related terms

Frequently asked questions

First of all, you should register to be able to purchase at auction. After confirming your email address, enter your personal information in your user profile, such as your first name, last name, and mail address. Choose a lot from the upcoming auction and the maximum amount you want to place on it. After confirmation of your choice, we will send your application by e-mail to the appropriate auction house. If the auction house accepts a request, it will participate in the auction. You can view the current status of a bid at any time in your personal account in the "Bids" section.
Auctions are performed by auction houses and each of the auction houses describes their terms of auction. You can see the texts in the section "Auction information".
The results of the auction are published within a few days after the end of the auction. In the top menu of the site, find the tab "Auctions". Click on it and you will be on the auction catalog page, where you can easily find the category "Results". After opening it, select the desired auction from the list, enter and view the current status of the interested lot.
The information about the auction winners is confidential. The auction winner will receive a direct notification from the auction house responsible with instructions for further action: an invoice for payment and the manner in which the goods will be received.
Each of the auction houses has its own payment policy for the won lots. All auction houses accept bank transfers, most of them accept credit card payments. In the near future you will find detailed information for each case in the section "Auction information" on the page of the auction catalog and the lot.
Shipment of the won lot depends on its size. Small items can be delivered by post. Larger lots are sent by courier. Employees of the auction houses will offer you a wide range to choose from.
No. The archive serves as a reference for the study of auction prices, photographs and descriptions of works of art.